Check your inbox right now. How many unread community invitations are sitting there?

I have three. I want to join two of them. But I won't.

Why? Responding feels like work.

This is the dirty secret of community building nobody talks about:

We spend hours on the perfect welcome email. We design beautiful invitation templates. We write compelling copy about why someone should join.

Then we wonder why our engagement rates are dismal.

The problem isn't your copy. It's not your design. It's the method itself.

The Email Invitation Death Spiral

Walk through what happens when you send a community invitation via email:

Step 1: Gmail filters most community invitations into the "Social" tab. 93% never make it to your primary inbox. Your invitation is being hidden before anyone sees it.

Step 2: Say your email beats the algorithm. Someone opens it. Now they have to read through the entire thing to figure out what you want them to do.

Step 3: They click a link. Gets taken to another page. Has to create an account. Verify their email. Fill out a profile with information they've entered a dozen times before. Wait for approval.

By this point? You've lost them.

People want to join. You've made the process too hard.

Every additional click is a chance for them to say "I'll do this later." Every form field is another barrier. Every moment of confusion is an exit ramp.

And "later" means never.

The Text Message Test

Here's the contrast:

When someone texts me or sends a Partiful link, I respond in seconds. My info is already saved. Yes or no. One tap.

Done.

People want to join communities the same way they RSVP to parties.

When was the last time someone invited you to a party via a formal email with multiple links and form fields?

Never.

You get a text. A Partiful or Evite link. You tap yes. You're in.

Minimal work. Almost zero friction. Simple process.

What The Data Shows

The numbers tell the story:

• SMS has a 98% open rate. Email? 20-39%.
• Text messages get responses in 90 seconds on average. Email takes 90 minutes (if you get a response at all).

And before you say "but older people don't text"...

Texting is now universal across all age groups. Even older folks who weren't early adopters are fluent in SMS now. The "professionalism" argument for email is outdated.

Community builders keep defaulting to long, formal email invitations because they look professional or fashionable.

But here's the thing: the perceived professionalism is killing engagement.

The Real Problem: We're Optimizing For The Wrong Thing

Here's what I see happening:

Community builders are optimizing for what feels impressive to them, not what works for their members.

A beautifully designed email with thoughtful copy and professional branding feels like you're doing the right thing. Feels substantial. Feels like you care.

But your members?

They don't care about your email design. They care about whether joining your community is worth the effort you're asking them to expend.

Right now, you're asking for way too much effort.

The communities thriving right now aren't the ones with the most polished emails. They're the ones making engagement easier:

• SMS invitations
• Direct messages on platforms people already use
• Simple one-click links
• Removing barriers between interest and participation

What This Means For Your Community

If you're relying on email as your primary invitation strategy, you're leaving engagement on the table.

Not because email is dead. Because you're making people jump through too many hoops.

The fix isn't complicated:

• Stop adding steps. Start removing them.

Meet people where they already are.

• Use the communication methods they respond to.
• Make saying yes as easy as possible.

Your community's success isn't measured by how professional your invitations look.

Measured by how many people show up.

‍