Blog
November 15, 2026
|
Michael Pedoeem

PastorsLine Alternatives for Small Churches: Stay for the Text In Church Move or Switch? (2026)

PastorsLine alternatives for small churches: stay with the Text In Church move or switch

What do you do when the texting app your church depends on gets bought?

If you're on PastorsLine, that's not a hypothetical. PastorsLine is now part of Text In Church, and as of November 2026 pastorsline.com redirects straight to textinchurch.com. Your real choice is between letting your account move into Text In Church, which keeps your number, or switching to one of the PastorsLine alternatives for small churches, like Clearstream, Text-Em-All or Evant. Which one fits depends mostly on one thing: did you use PastorsLine for texts, or for phone calls?

I run Evant, so I have a horse in this race. I'll tell you when the move to Text In Church is the smarter call. Sometimes it is.

Pricing and features checked November 2026 on each company's own site. Prices change, so confirm before you switch.

Quick answer

  • You're happy and you want zero work: let the Text In Church upgrade happen. Same number.
  • You used PastorsLine for voice broadcasts: check which Text In Church plan you land on. Voice broadcast is on PLUS and SUITE, not CORE.
  • Your church runs on Planning Center: Clearstream.
  • You mostly call people: Text-Em-All.
  • You want texts, calls, RSVPs and a donation page on one plan: Evant.

What actually happened to PastorsLine?

Text In Church announced it acquired PastorsLine on November 12, 2024. The same release says PastorsLine had a 10-day outage in September 2024 after its upstream provider faced a shutdown, and that Text In Church stepped in to restore service and keep phone numbers.

At first, the message was "PastorsLine will continue to operate as you know it for now."

Now it's a migration. Text In Church's transition page for PastorsLine customers says accounts are upgraded in groups, with advance notice. Here's what it says moves over and what you have to do:

  • Your texting number stays the same.
  • Your data, workflows and preferences move to Text In Church.
  • You'll be asked for A2P 10DLC registration details: EIN, legal address, website, and a staff contact listed on your website.
  • Downtime is about 30 minutes if you submit that when notified. About 24 hours if you don't.
  • Billing won't change "anytime soon," but it will eventually adjust to the new platform.

That last line is the one I'd circle. Nobody knows your future price yet.

Should you just let the upgrade happen?

For a lot of small churches, yes.

You keep your number. Your contacts come with you. You pick up unlimited email and automated workflows that mix texts and emails, according to the transition page. And Text In Church is good at guest follow-up. That's its whole thing. I compare the two products head to head in Evant vs Text In Church.

Here's my issue with going on autopilot, though.

Text In Church pricing is credit-based. Go over your plan and it's 3¢ per credit on your next bill. Voice broadcast is only on PLUS and SUITE. The Calling add-on is $10 per seat a month. I walk through every tier in Text In Church pricing 2026.

Now look at why many churches picked PastorsLine in the first place. In the acquisition release, a PastorsLine customer said his church had it "solely because of the phone broadcast feature."

If that's you, the plan you land on matters. A lot.

PastorsLine alternatives for small churches, side by side

OptionStarting priceHow you're chargedPhone callsBest for
Let the Text In Church upgrade happenSet by credit volume in their calculatorCredits, then 3¢ per credit over your planVoice broadcast on PLUS and SUITE. Calling add-on $10/seat/moYou like the PastorsLine team and want the least work
Clearstream$35/mo for 1,000 creditsCredits. Incoming texts are freeVoice on plans from $119/moPlanning Center churches
Text-Em-AllCredits from 9¢ each (400 minimum), or $19/mo for up to 50 peoplePay-as-you-go credits, or monthly by group size1 credit per 30-second message. Calls included on the monthly planChurches that mostly call
EvantFrom $20/moBy planEvery plan, 1.5¢ a minuteTexts, calls, RSVPs and giving in one place

Clearstream: best if you live in Planning Center

Clearstream starts at $35 a month for 1,000 credits. Only outgoing texts use credits. Incoming texts are free. Church plants under a year old can use it free.

The catch for former PastorsLine churches is calls. Voice is only available on US plans from $119 a month. If you called people every week, that's a big jump. I did the full small-church math in Clearstream alternatives for small churches.

Text-Em-All: best if calls are the main job

Text-Em-All treats calls and texts the same way. On pay-as-you-go, one credit is one text up to 160 characters, or one 30-second voice message. Credits start at 9¢ each, with a 400-credit minimum ($36), and they don't expire.

There's also a monthly plan priced by how many people you reach, starting at $19 for up to 50 contacts. Calls don't cost extra on it.

Where it loses: it isn't built for churches, and the monthly plan has fewer features than the credit plan.

Evant: best if you need texts, calls and replies in one place

Mine. Grain of salt.

Plans start at $20 a month, with a free trial and no credit card. Voice calls are on every plan at 1.5¢ a minute. Not an upgrade. Not a seat add-on. Every plan.

People reply YES to RSVP by text and you get a live headcount. Every customer gets a customizable Stripe donation page at no extra charge, plus free email. It works on every phone, flip phones included, and nobody downloads an app.

And since you're redoing A2P 10DLC registration either way, it helps that we handle it for you. You get a dedicated 10-digit number.

Where Evant loses: Text In Church's guest follow-up tools are deeper, and if a tight Planning Center sync is a must, Clearstream is ahead.

Before you switch: three questions to ask any provider

Can I keep my current number? Text In Church says yes for PastorsLine accounts. Anyone else, ask before you sign. Don't assume.

What does a 30-second call to 200 people cost? Get the number in dollars, not credits.

Who handles 10DLC registration? Business texting on 10-digit numbers runs through A2P 10DLC, and The Campaign Registry verifies brands before they're allowed to send. Some platforms do the paperwork for you. Some hand you a form.

One more thing, and I say this as someone who sells calls. Calls aren't always the answer. Don't call when a text would do. Use the phone broadcast for the people who can't get a text, not for everyone by default.

Why this is worth an hour of your time

Tools change under you. It happens.

When GroupMe shut down its SMS feature, tens of thousands of users scrambled. There was a petition asking GroupMe to keep it. Plain SMS just works.

A migration email is the best excuse you'll get to check that your texting tool still fits what your church does. Maybe it does. Good. Now you know.

Want the wider field? See my roundup of the best SMS platforms for churches.

FAQ

Is PastorsLine still in business?

PastorsLine is now part of Text In Church, which announced the acquisition on November 12, 2024. As of November 2026, pastorsline.com redirects to textinchurch.com, and PastorsLine accounts are being upgraded into Text In Church in phases.

Will I keep my phone number if my PastorsLine account moves to Text In Church?

Yes. Text In Church's transition page says your texting number stays the same and your data, workflows and preferences move over. You'll be asked to submit A2P 10DLC registration details, and downtime is about 30 minutes if you do that when notified, or about 24 hours if you don't.

Does Text In Church have voice broadcast like PastorsLine?

Yes, but not on every plan. Voice broadcast is included on Text In Church's PLUS and SUITE plans, not on CORE. Their separate Calling add-on is $10 per seat per month.

What is the best PastorsLine alternative for a small church?

It depends on what you used PastorsLine for. If you want the least work, accept the Text In Church upgrade. If you use Planning Center, look at Clearstream, which starts at $35 a month. If calls matter as much as texts, Text-Em-All and Evant both include voice, and Evant plans start at $20 a month with calls at 1.5¢ a minute.

So should your church stay or switch?

If you mostly text and you like the people behind PastorsLine, let the upgrade happen and keep your number.

If you relied on phone broadcasts, price out the Text In Church plan you'll actually need before your bill changes. Then compare it with Clearstream, Text-Em-All and Evant.

At the end of the day, you didn't choose to switch. But you do get to choose where you land.

👉 Start your free trial. No credit card.

Related Blogs

Your community is one text away.

Join hundreds of communities already using Evant to fill events, coordinate volunteers, and stay connected all year.
Try the Platform
Get Started Now